animal liberation is fiction.
it is the stuff of fairy tales, of make-believe, of magical fantasies.
it is wishful thinking, daydreaming.
it is a fabricated concept.
it is an invented premise.
it is an imaginary future.
animal liberation does not exist.
what does animal liberation look like?
sure – there are many happy, safe animals living with us today. even as i write these words, there are 3 content animals sleeping beside me.
but none of this translates to “animal liberation”, at least in the grander scheme of lived reality, which is what i think many of us dream about when we talk and organize for a future beyond speciesism.
to me, “animal liberation” on a broader, collective level would be a future where our humyn species can live communally with other earthling species, and do so outside systems of domination and exploitation.
so whether we focus our efforts on cultivating a liberated existence first from within us, or instead in our environments through empowering community organizing, both paths lead us into the wild unknown.
and this wild unknown of “animal liberation” means moving looking for something that you have never, ever seen before. perhaps we all don’t know where it is or when we will come upon it, but we trust that we will know it when we do meet it. or maybe we have already passed it by, and in our hurry to find the obvious solution to speciesism, we have neglected the simple, basic answers that require no special gifts or talents to receive and put into practice?
“We live in capitalism, its power seems inescapable – but then, so did the divine right of kings.” Ursula Le Guin
either way, the point remains that we all share the burden of having absolutely no template of experience, of memory, or of historical knowledge to draw upon when we advocate for the “liberation” of ourselves, of others, and for all the animals.
all speculation about the liberation of animals revolves around imagining
a) what animal liberation might look like, and
b) the ways in which we might manifest that vision.
what does animal liberation look like?
what does a world look like without zoos, rodeos and marine-parks?
how different would things be in a future where animals are not “farmed” for their fur, their muscle meat or their breast milk?
animal liberation is fiction, because imagining a world without cages is as fantastical as anything you might read in science fiction & fantasy.
artwork credit to Hartmut Kiewert
well, i don’t mean to sound facetious when animal liberation is the stuff of fantasy – i mean instead that both fiction and animal liberation rely upon our capacities to imagine and speculate something that is not (yet) here, not already existing, not a “fact” that can be proven.
and both follow the simple formula of sampling from existing situations & familiar struggles in humyn existence.
science fiction projects a potential future available given current technology and research – and then it weaves together a story from there, like explaining how the exponential growth of artificial intelligence suggests a near future where sentient super-intelligence revolts against humyn civilization.
fantasy fiction is a broader projection of the things we assume cannot ever happen – and then it weaves together a story from there, like explaining how the core of the planet is so terribly hot because there are fire-breathing dragons hibernating inside and whom may wake up tomorrow.
and what that all means is that animal liberation looks like fiction. it looks like science fiction. it looks like fantasy.
for the very act of speculating radical imaginative ideas is liberating.
so it follows – speculative fiction can look like animal liberation.
what are ways to manifest this vision of animal liberation?
to write and read radical fiction is to manifest visions of animal liberation, because whether we are author or reader, we are asking the question:
“what is the world we want to live in actually look like?”
and when we campaign in the streets or produce content to share or when we organize online, we are making efforts towards a version of reality that we deem more accountable, loving and anti-oppressive. yet all these efforts are attempts to manifest something not yet existing, something speculative, something fictional.
Walidah Imarisha, the educator, writer, organizer and spoken word artist who coined the term visionary fiction (to describe how we can use science fiction, horror, and fantasy genres to envision alternatives to unjust and oppressive systems), explained how:
“All organizing is science fiction.
When organizers imagine a world without poverty, without war, without borders or prisons—that’s science fiction.
They’re moving beyond the boundaries of what is possible or realistic, into the realm of what we are told is impossible.”
Walidah, along with adrienne maree brown, collected and edited a radical anthology of short stories that explore the connections between speculative fiction and movements for social change.
both Walidah and adrienne have emphasized, in writings and spoken word, that “there are as many ways to exist as we can imagine”. so by using speculative fiction to reach and inspire imaginations of wider audiences, we can nurture our collective imagination and make any fiction more alive, more feasible and more real.
from left to right, co-editors Walidah Imarisha and adrienne maree brown with Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha at the 2015 INCITE! Color of Violence conference
adrienne explained further how visionary fiction is:
“A perfect testing ground to explore the countless alternatives that could exist to policing and institutions like prisons.
It’s incredibly important that we begin to shift our thinking away from the state keeping us safe, given that that has never been the purpose of the state—it’s never been the purpose of the police or the prison system—and instead begin to ask, how do we keep each other safe?
How do we prevent harm from happening?
How do we address harm when it does happen in our communities in ways that are about healing, and about wholeness, rather than about punishment and retribution?”
and further, adrienne says how visionary fiction is political because:
“Being able to create and imagine bigger is a process of decolonization of our dreams.
Our dreams have gotten smaller and smaller, but as we engage sci-fi in reading and in dreams, our imaginations can grow and decolonize.”
so in applying their emotional labour and wisdoms to the issue of animal politics means liberating ourselves to imagine and then re-imagine what the liberation of animals could look like.
writing radical fiction for animal liberation
“We’ll need writers who can remember freedom – poets, visionaries – realists of a larger reality”.
Ursula Le Guin
radical fiction is a tool, an art form, available to all of us wishing to explore social political issues through a new lens of perspective. if you feel inspired to write radical fiction, or at least inclined to try reading some of it, then remember that the intention of this art is to communicate deep themes outside the narratives of the mainstream.
this means fiction that focuses attention on marginalized identities, and not the typical cis-hetero white able-minded-bodied male.
this means fiction that focuses on relevant problems in all its varied complexities, and not the trope of evil faceless tyrants wishing to conquer all that is “white and pure and free”.
this means fiction that is both realistic and honest but remains empowering and hopeful.
and so not stories about collective change coming from the top of the political hierarchies, nor stories about token heroes & animal characters used as anthropomorphic instruments to validate the humyn ego.
instead, by weaving the struggles and limitations towards liberation into an engaging story, and by creating characters who are not victims of the system but survivors and grounded leaders, all of this can become real lessons for us all to learn from and inspire towards.
whether you are writing and/or reading it for expanding your imagination persynally or for the sake of anti-oppressive community organizing, remember that the core of the story always needs to be about hope.
a new hope that comes from things to come for what we choose to do today, choose to do now, for choosing to not relent but to endure.
“In April we cannot see sunflowers in France, so we say the sunflowers do not exist.
But the local farmers have already planted thousands of seeds and when they look at the bare hills they may be able to see the sunflowers already.
The sunflowers are there.
They lack only the conditions of sun, heat, rain, and July. Just because we cannot see them does not mean they do not exist.”
– Thich Nhat Hanh
by using fiction as a platform for exploring new alternatives to anti-speciesism strategies, perhaps we can discover answers that have been buried and hidden by the systems of oppression. perhaps the system depends on us all continuing to feel trapped and lost and hopeless?
“Remember this: We be many and they be few. They need us more than we need them.
Another world is not only possible, she is on her way. On a quiet day, I can hear her breathing.”
perhaps even the smallest hints of hope, of hoping for hope, to find meaning and purpose to exist however we dare to imagine, perhaps that is where we will find the liberation of animals.